9 comments

  • singpolyma3 1 hour ago
    Love this.

    It says MIT license but then readme has a separate section on prohibited use that maybe adds restrictions to make it nonfree? Not sure the legal implications here.

    • CGamesPlay 34 minutes ago
      For reference, the MIT license contains this text: "Permission is hereby granted... to deal in the Software without restriction, including without limitation the rights to use". So the README containing a "Prohibited Use" section definitely creates a conflicting statement.
    • jandrese 34 minutes ago
      The "prohibited uses" section seems to be basically "not to be used for crime", which probably doesn't have much legal weight one way or another.
    • iamrobertismo 14 minutes ago
      Yeah, I don't understand the point of the prohibited use section at all, seems like unnecessary fluff.
    • Buttons840 38 minutes ago
      Good question.

      If a license says "you may use this, you are prohibited from using this", and I use it, did I break the license?

  • lukebechtel 1 hour ago
    Nice!

    Just made it an MCP server so claude can tell me when it's done with something :)

    https://github.com/Marviel/speak_when_done

  • armcat 2 hours ago
    Oh this is sweet, thanks for sharing! I've been a huge fan of Kokoro and event setup my own fully-local voice assistant [1]. Will definitely give Pocket TTS a go!

    [1] https://github.com/acatovic/ova

    • gropo 1 hour ago
      Kokoro is better for tts by far

      For voice cloning, pocket tts is walled so I can't tell

      • echelon 37 minutes ago
        What are the advantages of PocketTTS over Kokoro?

        It seems like Kokoro is the smaller model, also runs on CPU in real time, and is more open and fine tunable. More scripts and extensions, etc., whereas this is new and doesn't have any fine tuning code yet.

        I couldn't tell an audio quality difference.

    • amrrs 1 hour ago
      Thanks for sharing your repo..looks super cool.. I'm planning to try out. Is it based on mlx or just hf transformers?
      • armcat 1 hour ago
        Thank you, just transformers.
  • dust42 1 hour ago
    Good quality but unfortunately it is single language English only.
    • phoronixrly 1 hour ago
      I echo this. For a TTS system to be in any way useful outside the tiny population of the world that speaks exclusively English, it must be multilingual and dynamically switch between languages pretty much per word.

      Cool tech demo though!

      • kamranjon 50 minutes ago
        That's a pretty crazy requirement for something to be "useful" especially something that runs so efficiently on cpu. Many content creators from non-english speaking countries can benefit from this type of release by translating transcripts of their content to english and then running it through a model like this to dub their videos in a language that can reach many more people.
        • phoronixrly 12 minutes ago
          You mean youtubers? And have to (manually) synchronise the text to their video, and especially when youtube apparently offers voice-voice translation out of the box to mine and many others' annoyance?
      • Levitz 40 minutes ago
        But it wouldn't be for those who "speak exclusively English", rather, for those who speak English. Not only that but it's also common to have system language set to English, even if one's language is different.

        There's about 1.5B English speakers in the planet.

        • phoronixrly 20 minutes ago
          Let's indeed limit the use case to the system language, let's say of a mobile phone.

          You pull up a map. All the street names are in the local language, and no, transliterating the local names to the English alphabet does not make them understandable when spoken by TTS.

          You pull up a browser, open up an article to read during your commute in your local language. You now have to reach for a translation model first before passing the data to the English-only TTS software.

          You're driving, one of your friends Signals you. Your phone UI is in English, you get a notification (interrupting your Spotify) saying 'Signal message', followed by 5 minutes of gibberish.

          But let's say you have a TTS model that supports your local language natively. Well due to the fact that '1.5B English speakers' apparently exist in the planet, many texts in other languages include English or Latin names and words. Now you have the opposite issue -- your TTS software needs to switch to English to pronounce these correctly...

          And mind you, these are just very simple use cases for TTS. If you delve into use cases for people with limited sight that experience the entire Internet, and all mobile and desktop applications (often having poor localisation) via TTS you see how mono-lingual TTS is mostly useless and would be switched for a robotic old-school TTS in a flash...

          > only that but it's also common to have system language set to English

          Ask a German whether their system language is English. Ask a French person. I can go on.

      • echelon 34 minutes ago
        English has more users than all but a few products.
  • tschellenbach 1 hour ago
    It's cool how lightweight it is. Recently added support to Vision Agents for Pocket. https://github.com/GetStream/Vision-Agents/tree/main/plugins...
  • syntaxing 1 hour ago
    Is there something similar for STT? I’m using whisper distill models and they work ok. Sometimes it gets what I say completely wrong.
  • GaggiX 2 hours ago
    I love that everyone is making their own TTS model as they are not as expensive as many other models to train. Also there are plenty of different architecture.

    Another recent example: https://github.com/supertone-inc/supertonic

  • oybng 59 minutes ago
    >If you want access to the model with voice cloning, go to https://huggingface.co/kyutai/pocket-tts and accept the terms, then make sure you're logged in locally with `uvx hf auth login` lol
  • snvzz 1 hour ago
    Relative to AmigaOS translator.device + narrator.device, this sure seems bloated.