The Letter S, by Donald Knuth (1980) [pdf]

(gwern.net)

47 points | by bambax 3 hours ago

4 comments

  • WillAdams 24 minutes ago
    His book _TeX and METAFONT_ (about the initial public release) goes into these difficulties in greater detail and includes the charming response by his wife when shown some initial efforts:

    >Why don't you make them _S_ shaped?

    To some degree, this problem was eventually solved, c.f., the five volume set _Computers and Typesetting_:

    https://www-cs-faculty.stanford.edu/~knuth/abcde.html

    but then one had the effort to create a new typeface set for math equations by the AMS, eventually named Euler as written up in "AMS Euler — a new typeface for mathematics". _Scholarly Publishing_ and so forth, but arguably, things went awry in that rather than capture the ductus of Prof. Zapf's pen, and model based on that stroke and a pen shape, the expedient approach of simply modeling the outline was arrived at and implemented due to the difficulty and lengthy time required for the idealized approach.

    Another consideration may have been that there doesn't seem to be an available algorithm which is robust and accurate and automatic for determining the curves which describe the union of arbitrary Bézier curves (some projects get around this by making high resolution pixel images and tracing them).

  • bombcar 30 minutes ago
    I just spent 30 minutes reading a detailed mathematical version of "draw an S; next draw a more different S".
  • mrandish 12 minutes ago
    Knuth is just a treasure.
  • adzm 22 minutes ago
    (1980)
    • dang 21 minutes ago
      Added. Thanks!