AI is becoming a disaster for the climate

(bloodinthemachine.com)

91 points | by Brajeshwar 9 hours ago

11 comments

  • 0x20cowboy 3 hours ago
    > An estimated 20 megatons of CO2-equivalent emissions per year

    > Animal agriculture produces an estimated 6.2 billion metric tons (6,200 megatons) of CO₂-equivalent emissions per year

    While it is possible to care about two things at once, if this was really about the climate and CO2 emissions I think people would focus elsewhere.

    This argument falls flat with me, and I care about climate change.

    • rsfern 3 hours ago
      On the other hand, the energy consumption isn’t static and my impression is that compute scaling is still a dominant mechanism for increasing model performance, both for RL post-training and test time compute scaling

      If we assume OpenAI will have similar power consumption and that emissions are linear in compute, then it’s only two more rounds of 10x increase in compute capacity to hit parity with animal agriculture

      I think that’s plausible enough to be worth more careful consideration and discussion. Hopefully investments in more efficient models continue to pay off quickly enough to offset this, but failing that I’m not convinced the frontier labs will stop pursuing compute scaling just because it’s environmentally unsustainable

      • Grombobulous 7 minutes ago
        Why would we assume two more rounds of 10x increase?

        Are we assuming that chips just stop getting more power efficient?

        Are we assuming that AI never reaches saturation? About half of US adults already use AI.

      • 0x20cowboy 2 hours ago
        The less power they use the more money they make whereas in most other industries they either dont care, or want you to use more energy. Seems like the incentives are more aligned here.
    • oliwarner 3 hours ago
      Doesn't the growth projection of it being half of all animal agriculture in ten years not concern you? Using the same power as the activity to feed 5 billion people seems a bit much.
    • 1vuio0pswjnm7 15 minutes ago
      "While it is possible to care about two things at once, if this was really about the climate and CO2 emissions I think people would focus elsewhere."

      What's it "really about"

    • jraph 2 hours ago
      Top comment: whataboutism. AI threads never disappoint here.

      > While it is possible to care about two things at once

      It is, actually. Full stop.

      And there is no reason not to fight against a new threat particularly hard, even when old threats are already there.

      One doesn't necessarily write about plant based diets each time one writes about AI's environmental impacts, because mixing things isn't particularly effective.

      • kriops 2 hours ago
        Not at zero cost. Thus it is not whataboutism.

        You need to be an eco-extremist (or just disconnected from reality) to read GP as anything other than a very reasonable value judgement.

        • watwut 4 minutes ago
          It absolutely is bad faith whataboutism whose whole point is to distract and create yet another cukture war about eating.
        • jraph 2 hours ago
          Sorry, I need some clarification to understand your comment.

          What's an eco-extremist, already?

          Don't bother answering, actually. I prefer not knowing.

    • snowe2010 3 hours ago
      Animals feed people. LLMs do not. This has to be the worst argument you could come up with.
      • thi2 3 hours ago
        People can be fed without animals, it would be healthier and better for the climate.
    • biscuit1v9 3 hours ago
      same for me

      there are people who even hate EVs just because producing batteries pollutes a lot and proceed to get a normal car because it's not just "a battery on wheels"

      or the people who don't eat animals to save the planet and have a better environment

    • kriops 2 hours ago
      I'm not saying it is Russian/Chinese FUD, but it may as well be.
  • nkurz 8 hours ago
    This was flagged dead, but I vouched to revive it. It seems like a decent overview article of a couple recent papers on the potential climate impact of AI. It doesn't feel AI generated itself---which admittedly would be ironic! Even if you think the whole climate narrative is bunk, please explain why in a comment rather than flagging this away. Or am I missing some reason this particular writeup isn't worthy of discussion?
  • skwon816 4 hours ago
    Regardless of our opinion on data centers, I think they should be fully transparent about the information
  • isodev 8 hours ago
    I think as a planet (forget about borders and superpowers already) we need to ask ourselves where we want this to go.

    Wrecking the little natural resources we have left just to pretend we’ve invented “intelligence” seems rather illogical. We’re still very much just simple “post-industrial barbarians”.

    • sl0wbrainRot 5 hours ago
      The environment thing was an issue for longer than AI:

      https://news.harvard.edu/gazette/story/2023/01/harvard-led-a...

      Film industry, video game industry, car industry, air travel industry, iPhone industry, Toys R Us industry... were they worth it?

      The "highly educated" YOLO'd it the last 60 years cause they'll be dead. Such an enlightened people all those "knowledge workers" who exploited labor and destroyed the environment.

      3C in 50 years is locked in. Get ready for Mad Max as famines, equator becomes a heat bubble around the globe force mass migrations at the last minute since no one will pay attention until the last minute.

  • lurker137 3 hours ago
    Of all the climate polluting technologies out there, at least AI is one that has a non-zero chance of reversing climate change
    • watwut 3 minutes ago
      No it does not. There is nothing about creating one knowledge and power center that could solve climate change.
  • dyauspitr 1 hour ago
    I think Spain had the perfect solution to this that you mandate on a nation level that all data centers have to be 80% powered by renewables they made sure to put in the right caveats, for instance you’ll have to directly buy the renewable electricity for that 80%, you can’t offset it by buying carbon offsets
  • xg15 4 hours ago
    Anthropic's ethics points are already exhausted by their pledge not to eradicate humanity through uncontrolled runaway superintelligence. (They only do controlled runaway superintelligence). You can't expect them to also deal with small problems like climate change at that level!
  • RickJWagner 3 hours ago
    AI is bringing change to the future of work.

    What used to take many, many hours of research is now nearly instant. Software projects are greatly compressed. One worker, with AI, can do the work of many without it.

    All this means less resource usage.

    A fair article would factor these in.

    • dc3k 49 minutes ago
      > One worker, with AI, can do the work of many without it.

      > All this means less resource usage.

      Can you explain your math here, because this doesn't make any sense whatsoever.

      Workers are still working the same amount of hours they always did, they're just doing way more work in that time via AI systems. How exactly does this result in _less_ resource usage?

      The only change AI is bringing to the future of work is that it's squeezing way more productivity out of employees at no benefit to them.

    • snowe2010 3 hours ago
      lol do you actually think less resources are being used? Please do provide a study showing that.
  • titaniumrain 5 hours ago
    [dead]
  • pjmlp 4 hours ago
    No worries, paper straws and glued bottle caps is what matters. /s
  • 217 8 hours ago
    No it does not. This is just not true at all and is only written to support authors' point of view

    There are many way, way more applicable reasons to be disapproving of ai than climate change, this ain't it whatsoever

    • nkurz 8 hours ago
      OK, that's a start. Is this because the studies are wrong and increased use of AI isn't actually going to dramatically increase fossil fuel usage, or because increased fossil fuel consumption isn't actually something that we should worry about?

      I'm sure there are arguments for both of these (clean energy will quickly replace the dirty initial sources/why worry about decadal scale global warming in the face of FOOM?) but it would help if you actually made some arguments rather than just gesturing.

      • adjejmxbdjdn 5 hours ago
        It’s hard to see how increased fossil fuel consumption will not be a problem given that we haven’t modeled tipping points at all.

        However, focusing on the AI industry is beyond silly.

        For example, this article focuses on the 25.7 million metric ton Co2E the 400 largest data centers emit (and I suspect this is data centers, not AI data centers specifically), and let’s say the total data center emission in the U.S. is 3 times that.

        So that’s about 75million MTCO2E

        Well, the US dairy industry alone emits about 160 million MTCO2E in a year. And dairy is a trivially substitutable product (with half a dozen plant based direct alternatives, but frankly, the US dairy industry would likely collapse if it wasn’t for the subsidies showered on it by the government), nd has a whole host of other issues.

        AI on the other hand is doing completely new rhinfs, and is likely more efficient than the alternative ways of doing the same stuff.

        If you’re seriously concerned about emissions start with eliminating subsidies to the dairy industry. That alone would wipe out half the industry and buy you enough emissions saved to more than offset AI emissions for another decade.

        What this really shows is that this is not being taken seriously but is close to essentially clickbait (the research is necessary, but the idea that AI is even close to the biggest emissions concern is the clickbait aspect).

        • snowe2010 3 hours ago
          It’s wiping out any gains we have made in the past few years and accelerating in the opposite direction. This article only discussed the pollution aspect, not the heating or water loss aspects. The effect is much much greater than a number of increased emissions. It’s backsliding work we’ve taken for decades to get to and saying “fuck it all” for a chatbot that has none to negative benefit to all of society.
        • xg15 4 hours ago
          The 75 million are in addition to what the diary industry is already emitting and evidently much letts entwined with and necessary for the wider economy as the diary industry.

          It's a bit like sitting in a car, driving in the opposite direction of where you have to go, and then accelerating - but then saying "well, I only accelerated a little!"

          • adjejmxbdjdn 4 hours ago
            For that analogy to work, it’s as if your accelerator is being driven by a stack of blocks pushing the pedal down.

            Your lowest block is 25lbs, the next one is 15lbs, the next one is 10lbs, and now you’ve added a block that’s another 5lbs.

            It would be complaining about the last 5lbs gold block and asking for that to be removed and thrown away, but ignoring the 15lbs brick that’s made of stone and not very valuable.

            The fact that the AI emissions are newer is no reason to give that additional scrutiny. The scrutiny should be directed to the parts of the problems that are bigger and have less value and are more easily substitute able.

          • jkahrs595 4 hours ago
            the dairy industry is only "necessary" because of the dairy lobby